Lucy Fitzgerald 
Joe Kelly & The Royal Pharmacy’s sophomore album, Cast Me Down, released on April 11, 2025, via Dirty Carrot Records, is a bold and genre-defying journey that solidifies Kelly’s place as a dynamic force in the indie music scene. While their debut, World On Fire, introduced listeners to their indie Americana roots, Cast Me Down ventures into uncharted territories, blending elements of psychedelic pop, soul, garage rock, and experimental soundscapes.
From the opening track, “200 Years,” the album sets a tone of audacious exploration. The title track, “Cast Me Down,” delves into themes of doomed love and self-doubt, drawing inspiration from Kelly’s Catholic upbringing. The song’s moody grandeur is reminiscent of the Arctic Monkeys’ late-night experiments at Rancho de la Luna and the cinematic pop of latter-day Black Keys .
The album’s eclecticism is further showcased in tracks like “Little Fears,” which channels spooky 60s psych-pop vibes, and “Living Daylights,” featuring a psychedelic crescendo highlighted by Scott McKeon’s violin work . Erin McNamara’s soulful vocals add depth and contrast, particularly on tracks like “Fill My Soul” .
Producer Jon Greening’s influence is evident throughout the album, providing a cohesive yet adventurous sonic landscape. The band’s willingness to push boundaries results in a record that is both unpredictable and captivating.
Cast Me Down is a triumphant follow-up that not only meets but exceeds the expectations set by their debut. It’s a testament to Joe Kelly & The Royal Pharmacy’s artistic growth and their commitment to crafting music that is both innovative and emotionally resonant. This album is a must-listen for anyone seeking a rich and immersive musical experience.
You can listen to the title track, “Cast Me Down,” on YouTube:
Listening to songs so you don’t have to! Just kidding :D, you totally should. Music blogger by day, nurse by night
